The internet is no stranger to wild theories, but few have captured the collective imagination quite like the “Trisha Paytas Baby Theory.” This bizarre phenomenon suggests that every time YouTuber and influencer Trisha Paytas gives birth, a famous figure passes away, sparking debates about mysticism, reincarnation, and sheer coincidence.
With the recent death of rock legend Ozzy Osbourne coinciding with the birth of Paytas’ third child, the theory has exploded across social media, leaving many to wonder | is there something supernatural at play, or is this just the internet doing what it does best—finding patterns where none may exist?
Who Is Trisha Paytas?
Before we delve into the mystical connections, let’s set the stage by introducing Trisha Paytas, the central figure in this curious saga. Paytas, 37, is a polarizing yet undeniably influential internet personality who has been a fixture on YouTube since 2007. Known for her candid vlogs, mukbangs, and self-released pop music, she’s built a massive following through her unfiltered approach to life. From reality TV stints on Celebrity Big Brother to her explosive Frenemies podcast with Ethan Klein, Paytas has a knack for staying in the headlines, whether through viral moments or controversies.
Paytas is also a mother of three, sharing her journey with husband Moses Hacmon and their children | Malibu Barbie (born September 14, 2022), Elvis (born May 24, 2024), and Aquaman Moses (born July 12, 2025). Her openness about her pregnancies and family life has endeared her to fans, but it’s also what sparked the peculiar theory tying her children’s births to the deaths of global icons.
The Origins of the Trisha Paytas Baby Theory
The “Trisha Paytas Baby Theory” first emerged in September 2022, when Paytas announced she was in labor with her first child, Malibu Barbie. Just hours before, news broke that Queen Elizabeth II had passed away at the age of 96. The eerie timing caught the attention of social media users, who began joking that Paytas’ daughter was the reincarnation of the late monarch. What started as a lighthearted meme quickly snowballed into a viral phenomenon, with users on TikTok and X speculating about a mystical connection. Paytas herself addressed the rumor in a TikTok video, dismissing it as “poor taste” and expressing discomfort with the attention, especially given the gravity of the Queen’s death.
Despite her attempts to downplay the speculation, the theory gained traction, fueled by the internet’s love for conspiracies and coincidences. As Paytas continued to grow her family, the pattern seemed to repeat, cementing her place at the center of this bizarre narrative.
A Timeline of Coincidences | Births and Deaths
Let’s break down the timeline of events that have fueled the Trisha Paytas Baby Theory, examining each instance where her children’s births coincided with the passing of a famous figure.
September 2022 | Malibu Barbie and Queen Elizabeth II
On September 8, 2022, Queen Elizabeth II, Britain’s longest-reigning monarch, passed away at Balmoral Castle. Hours earlier, Paytas announced she was in labor with her first child. On September 14, she welcomed daughter Malibu Barbie Paytas-Hacmon. The proximity of these events sparked immediate speculation, with X users joking, “Trisha Paytas is 1 for 1” and suggesting that Malibu was the Queen reincarnated. While Paytas denied the connection, the internet ran with it, creating memes and viral posts that kept the theory alive.
May 2024 | Elvis and Pope Francis (Debunked)
The theory evolved with the birth of Paytas’ second child, Elvis Paytas-Hacmon, on May 24, 2024. Around this time, false rumors circulated that Pope Francis had died. In reality, Pope Francis passed away nearly a year later, on April 21, 2025. Despite the inaccuracy, some internet users linked Elvis’ birth to the Pope, claiming it fit the pattern. Paytas addressed this in a TikTok, noting the “crazy timing” but urging fans to focus on her baby’s arrival rather than conspiracies. This instance highlighted the theory’s resilience, as believers stretched the timeline to fit their narrative.
July 2025 | Aquaman Moses and Ozzy Osbourne
The most recent and widely discussed coincidence occurred on July 12, 2025, when Paytas gave birth to her third child, a son named Aquaman Moses Paytas-Hacmon. On July 22, news broke that Ozzy Osbourne, the legendary Black Sabbath frontman, had died at 76 after a battle with Parkinson’s disease. The announcement came mere hours after Paytas shared her son’s birth on Instagram, prompting an avalanche of comments like “Welcome back, Ozzy!” and “Trisha Paytas is 3 for 3.” The timing reignited the theory, with X users posting, “Ozzy Osbourne dead just hours after Trisha Paytas gives birth oh she is NEVER beating the allegations.”
Other Speculated Connections
Some fans have tried to tie Paytas’ second pregnancy to King Charles III’s cancer diagnosis in 2024, while others mistakenly linked her third child to the death of Donald Sutherland on June 20, 2024. However, these connections are less precise, as Sutherland’s death did not align closely with any of Paytas’ births, and King Charles is still alive as of July 2025. These attempts to expand the theory demonstrate the internet’s eagerness to find patterns, even when the evidence is shaky.
Mysticism or Coincidence? Exploring the Debate
The Trisha Paytas Baby Theory has sparked a lively debate, with opinions split between those who see it as a mystical phenomenon and those who dismiss it as pure coincidence. Let’s explore both sides.
The Case for Mysticism
For believers, the theory taps into ancient ideas of reincarnation and soul transfer. Some argue that Paytas is a “portal between worlds,” a conduit through which famous souls are reborn. The consistency of the timing—three births, three high-profile deaths—lends credence to this view for some. On X, one user wrote, “Trisha Paytas has officially reincarnated 3 people | Queen Elizabeth, Pope Francis, & Ozzy Osbourne, it’s getting scary.” The choice of her children’s unique names—Malibu Barbie, Elvis, and Aquaman—adds a layer of intrigue, as some fans speculate that the names reflect the personalities of the departed figures. For instance, Aquaman’s superhero moniker has been jokingly tied to Osbourne’s larger-than-life persona.
The theory also draws on cultural fascination with mysticism, particularly in online spaces where astrology, spirituality, and conspiracy theories thrive. Paytas’ own flair for the dramatic makes her an ideal figure for such a narrative, as her life already feels like a larger-than-life performance.
The Case for Coincidence
Skeptics argue that the theory is a classic example of confirmation bias, where people see patterns because they’re looking for them. The world is full of high-profile deaths, and with Paytas giving birth three times in three years, it’s statistically likely that some would coincide with notable passings. As one X user pointed out, “Trisha Paytas’ baby was born on July 12, and Ozzy died 10 days later. That’s not ‘the same day’—people are stretching this.” Critics also note that the Pope Francis connection was based on a false rumor, further undermining the theory’s credibility.
From a logical standpoint, correlation doesn’t equal causation. The internet’s tendency to amplify coincidences, especially around a figure as visible as Paytas, explains why the theory has taken off. Her openness about her pregnancies makes her a lightning rod for speculation, but there’s no evidence to suggest anything supernatural is at play.
Ozzy Osbourne’s Role in the Theory
Ozzy Osbourne’s death on July 22, 2025, has become the centerpiece of the latest wave of speculation. Known as the “Prince of Darkness,” Osbourne was a heavy metal pioneer with Black Sabbath and a successful solo artist. His larger-than-life persona, marked by infamous antics like biting the head off a bat, made him a cultural icon. His passing, just days after Paytas’ son Aquaman was born, felt like the perfect storm for conspiracy theorists.
The connection was further amplified by a curious detail | Jason Momoa, the actor who played Aquaman in the DC films, hosted Osbourne’s final concert at Villa Park in Birmingham earlier that month. This serendipitous link led some to joke that Aquaman Moses Paytas-Hacmon was destined to carry Osbourne’s rebellious spirit. One X user wrote, “Trisha Paytas’ son is named Aquaman, and Jason Momoa hosted Ozzy’s last show. This is too wild.”
What Does It All Mean?
So, is Trisha Paytas a mystical “portal between worlds,” or is she simply caught in a web of internet-fueled coincidences? The answer likely lies in perspective. For those who believe in reincarnation, the timing of her children’s births and the deaths of figures like Queen Elizabeth II and Ozzy Osbourne feels too precise to dismiss. For skeptics, it’s a reminder that humans are wired to find meaning in randomness, especially when amplified by social media.
What’s undeniable is the theory’s staying power. It has turned Paytas into an unlikely symbol of internet culture, where truth and fiction blur in the pursuit of a good story. As she continues to share her life online, fans and skeptics alike will be watching—perhaps with bated breath—for the next coincidence to fuel the saga.
